By the Indivisible East Bay Voter Rights and Election Integrity team
The Supreme Court’s Citizens United ruling eight years ago undermined our democracy by allowing those with unlimited money to use it to drown out the voices of the rest of us. While we would like to see Citizens United overturned, we should not wait for the Supreme Court to act – and we don’t have to. Here’s a good start: AB 2188, the Social Media DISCLOSE Act, currently pending in the California legislature, would lift the veil that lets big spenders influence politics while hiding their identities from us. (DISCLOSE is an acronym for Democracy Is Strengthened by Casting Light on Spending in Elections.)
The Social Media DISCLOSE Act isn’t the first piece of legislation to tackle this problem. As a 2017 California Clean Money Campaign (CCMC) press release explained, AB 249, the California DISCLOSE Act, requires television, radio, and print ads about ballot measures, and independent expenditures about candidates, to clearly list their top three funders. While AB 249 also has provisions relating to electronic media ads, the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) did not believe that it required social media platforms to comply. AB 2188 closes that loophole, requiring online social media platforms to disclose information regarding the funders of political advertisements and to keep a database of the political ads they run. AB 2188 specifically requires online platforms to display “Who funded this ad?” on each political ad, linking to the page of the paying committee.
The amounts of money involved in political races have always been high; they have now become stratospheric. According to Southern California Law Review, an estimated $1.4 billion was spent on online political advertising nationally in 2016 – nearly an eightfold increase from 2012! And if you think you’re seeing a lot of political ads on Facebook, you’re right – about 40% of that astonishing sum was spent there and on other social media ads. Virtually none of those ads disclosed who paid for them, so you never knew that $100,000 of those Facebook ads were bought by Russian entities. The federal Honest Ads Act, sponsored by Senator Amy Klobuchar and co-sponsored by Senator John McCain, was introduced in response to this threat, but – surprise! – it’s stuck in Congress.
A federal bill would be ideal, as would a Congress that would see it to conclusion. Things being less than ideal, a state like California should be able to stand up and defend itself from the influence of dark money, Super PACs and a handful of people who believe they have more right to be heard than everyone else in the country put together. In fact, AB 2188 is better than the federal bill in at least one way — it requires the web pages of the committees paying for online ads to clearly list the top three true funders – that way, individuals can’t hide behind nice-sounding committee names.
AB 2188 awaits a vote in the state Assembly Appropriations Committee. California Senate and Assembly committees represent all Californians, and the Appropriations Committee needs to hear from us in order for the Social Media DISCLOSE Act to pass!
Please call Appropriations Committee Chair Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher: (916) 319-2080, and Vice Chair Frank Bigelow: (916) 319-2005. What to say:
My name is ______, my zip code is _____, and I’m a member of Indivisible East Bay. I’m calling to ask Assemblymember ______ to support AB 2188, currently in the Appropriations Committee. Political ads on social media like Facebook should be required to disclose who pays for them. We should never again have to wonder who is trying to influence our vote. I urge ______ to vote yes on AB 2188.
If you live in Rob Bonta’s (AD 18, Oakland, 916-319-2018) or Bill Quirk’s (AD 20, Hayward, 916-319-2020) district, please call them too, using the same script as above. Be sure to let them know you are their constituent. As your representative and as members of the Appropriations Committee, Bonta and Quirk hold considerable power to help AB 2188.
Finally, please spread the word to anyone you know who lives in AD 18 or 20, or in any district of other members of the Appropriations Committee, especially people in San Diego, Committee Chair Fletcher’s district.
Graphic © California Clean Money Action Fund